There are no statistics

Good to read from Shaun @ UPI on a bill to support the mental health needs of homecoming US service personnel, on the day it was reported in the UK that executed WW1 soldiers, often suffering from ‘shellshock’, are to be pardoned.

A bill named after a young soldier who killed himself after returning from Iraq seeks better tracking of psychological trauma among veterans.

The Joshua Omvig Veterans Suicide Prevention Bill, HR 5771, currently before the U.S. House of Representatives, mandates the establishment of a comprehensive screening and counseling referral program for all returning veterans that would identify and track at-risk individuals, and provide more help for those with emotional or spiritual wounds.

Spc. Joshua Omvig left Iraq on his 21st birthday, Nov. 18, 2004 after an 11 month tour. “Five days later he was having Thanksgiving dinner with us,” his father Randy told United Press International in a telephone interview. “A week after that he was back at work” at his civilian job.

But his son never got over the experiences he had in Iraq. The young soldier “came back a different person,” his father said.

Spc. Omvig was depressed and uncommunicative. His family encouraged him
to seek counseling but he was reluctant. “He believed very strongly that
if he sought help it would adversely affect his military career,” said his father.

On Dec. 22, 2005, 13 months after returning from Iraq, Omvig took his own life. It would be a commonplace to say that in doing so, he became a statistic. But it would also be wrong. There are no statistics.

The figure commonly cited for veterans of Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan who have killed themselves is 79. But, as Omvig’s family are keen to point out, that count starts only in March 2003, and includes only those who were receiving care within the federal Veteran’s Administration healthcare system.

“There’s Joshua and lots of others who aren’t counted” because they never sought help, said his father.

And therein lies the problem.

A study published in July 2004 in the New England Journal of Medicine concluded that there was likely significant under-reporting of mental health problems among returning soldiers and marines.

Of those in the study’s sample who were screened positive for a mental disorder, “only 38 to 45 percent indicated an interest in receiving help, and only 23 to 40 percent reported having received professional help in the past year.”

“The subjects reported important barriers to receiving mental health
services, particularly the perception of stigma among those most in need
of such care,” concluded the study.

“Not all wounds inflected in combat are visible,” said Rep. Leonard Boswell, D-Iowa, one of the bill’s sponsors. “A simple screening and tracking process could have provided Joshua with the counseling he needed, saving his life.”

Omvig’s family stress the importance of a proactive approach. “What provision there is supposed to be at the moment… it’s mainly left up to the soldiers themselves or their families to diagnose,” said his father.

The bill would provide suicide prevention training for all Veterans’ Administration staff, contractors, and medical personnel.

“The same way swift triage care can save a soldier on the battlefield,” said Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, “accurate diagnosis and delivery of quality mental health care can do the same once the fighting ends.” With his fellow Iowan, GOP Sen. Charles Grassley, Harkin has introduced a senate version of the bill, S 3808.Supporters say they hope the legislation can be fitted in to the crowded legislative schedule of both chambers after the August recess.

In February 2006, there were more than 555,000 veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan, just over half of them from the National Guard or Reserve.About 168,000, or 30 percent of them, have so far sought help from theU.S. Department of Veteran’s Affairs healthcare system, which offers former troops free treatment for a wide range of ailments that might be
related to their service. Of those, 168,000 — almost exactly one third — had an initial diagnosis that included some form of mental illness, according to figures provided to lawmakers.

The bill would also try to engage the families of returning veterans, creating an education program help them understand the readjustment process for returning troops and recognize the signs and symptoms of mental illness.

“We spend a great deal of time and money training our troops to survive their deployment,” said Omvig’s father, “But we spend nothing when they return, making sure they can transition back… making sure they survive the peace.”

He said the problem was especially acute for guard and reserve veterans, especially in rural areas, who might live miles from their base and even further from the nearest Veteran’s Affairs Department facility. “There needs to be more outreach,” he said. “They need to get out there to where people are, to work with them there.”

The bill would ensure 24-hour access to mental health care for veterans who are deemed at risk for suicide, including those in rural or remote locations.

Since their own tragedy, Omvig’s family have found some comfort in pressing for change in the system they feel failed their son. “We feel,” began Omvig’s mother, Ellen, “that if some good can come out of the worst thing that ever happened to us…” but she trailed off.

“There’s nothing we can do for Josh now,” his father said, “but we can help others. This isn’t a political thing. As Americans, we made a promise to those young men that of they went out there and risked their lives for our country, we would look after them… I don’t think we are keeping that promise.”

Oliver Stone’d>Stone Mountain>

News of Oliver Stone’s new 9/11 film just in from our Shaun @ UPI. Funny, I recall trying to get an interview with Stone way back when I heard he was sniffing around a possible film about the assassination of Martin Luther King. I hassled a couple of his PR people but naturally being a stone-cold loser got nowhere. Stone says now it wasn’t gonna be a conspiracy movie, just so you know. But thanks to blogging, it’s now news! Anyhow, here’s the 9/11 week ahead:

Oliver Stone’s movie about Sept. 11, “World Trade Center,” is released Thursday. Ten percent of the gross take from the first five days of theatrical release will be donated to four New York-based charities that are working in different ways to memorialize the victims of the attack or provide ongoing support to their families. Several organizations (including this one and this one) have already indicated that they will use the movie to try and promote conspiracy theories about the attacks.

All-in-all, there’s likely to be quite a bit of Sept. 11 revisionism around this week, as the chairs of the blue-ribbon commission that investigated the attacks, Thomas Kean and Lee Hamilton, are also due to publish their account of the commission’s behind-the-scenes-struggles with the administration and congress. In advance of the book, there’s already been one new revelation — that the commission considered a criminal referral over the way they were decieved by NORAD and the Department of Defense.
The extent of that deception is thrown into sharp relief for your humble correspondent by the audio tapes published on the Vanity Fair Web site by a producer of the last Sept. 11 movie, Flight 93.

Now Kean tells the Washington Post that the commission was never able to ascertain why NORAD had tried to hide the real sequence of events. The Jersey Girls say that this admission “puts into question the veracity of the entire Commission’s report.”
I think that’s a stretch, personally, but I do think it shows there’s a danger that in hyping the importance of the book, coverage of it could end up leaving question marks over Kean and Hamilton’s earlier work — the commission’s own report.

Come to think of it wasn’t it Shaun when at BBC R4 who got me the job of covering the MLK 30th anniversary.